The Zim Family Cocker Spaniel Forum

Thanks for starting the thread. I think Jessica can really sing well, but I really didn't like the song she sang at all, so I'm not surprised she's was in the bottom 3. I think too many fans figured she was safe so they didn't need to vote. I'm enjoying the show, and sort of like Colton best, but I have to admit that so far I really don't like anyone well enough that I would buy their album.

I like Elise and Phillip Phillips. I am NOT a Jessica fan. I feel she is void of personality. She said twice on the show, "I have worked my whole life for this." Ummm she is 15. Elise is what 28....Definitely has worked a bit longer. I know Jessica can sing. But, she can only sing the belty ballads. When she has to sing fast, upbeat she sound awful.

But, I am enjoying this season. Even though the judges are quite a bit manic for my taste.

I miss Simon telling it like it is......

I thought I would join in on the fun; and share my top four:
Phillip Phillips
Elise
Colton
Joshua

just my two cent opinion
debbierg

Loved last night's show. I hardly ever go to concerts, but I did go to three of Queen's back when Freddie Mercury was still alive. I think Elise will get voted off tonight, or maybe Jessica, but it is hard to tell.

I thought Jessica would be going home. Last night wasn't her best and I don't think she has settled on the type of singer she wants to be. I thought Phil Phillips hit a home run with the Bob Seger song. Interestingly, my husband really likes Phillips and Seger and didn't like it at all!

My husband and I really liked Phillip Phillips. I have never been a Jessica or Joshua fan. But I did think it would be Jessica going home, not Joshua.

Me too! What a shocker!!!
I hope Phil Phillips win. I never really connected with Jessica. Phil has unique qualities. He is truly an artist and entertainer not just a singer.

I have been a real avid fan of American Idol until this season. I am just disappointed with the show this year. Maybe it's because I am not a big fan of the finalists, but I feel like something is missing for me this year. It's too bad because in years past I would never miss a show and this year I have missed more than a few. Cheryl, wasn't it you that would go to the show once a season? Did you make it this year?

I think PHillip will win as he has already a genre to immediate start recording. In the other hand JEssicavis an awesome singer who needs to define her style. She will definitively get there and sell many records. Both are great.